a group of people standing next to each other

The prospect of funding an additional 150,000 further education places for young people and a legal guarantee of a job may sound like a bold response to Britain’s growing Neet crisis, but according to a Birmingham City University (BCU) Professor, could be wholly ineffective without genuine economic growth.

Mike Leonard, Visiting Professor of Manufacturing and the Built Environment and co-lead of BCU’s Centre for Future Homes, says that whilst Alan Milburn’s review demonstrates a welcome recognition that too many young people are being left behind, the solution is not simply more education. 

“The uncomfortable truth is that Britain does not suffer from a shortage of people seeking opportunities. It suffers from a shortage of productive, well-paid jobs being created in the first place, and AI is likely to see many white-collar jobs disappear,” he said.

“For decades, governments of all political colours have responded to rising unemployment with a familiar formula: more training programmes, new qualifications and revised funding mechanisms.

“While these measures can improve employability, they do little if the jobs simply do not exist. Training people for employment opportunities that are not being created is like building a motorway that leads nowhere.

“What Britain urgently needs is economic growth that creates real jobs and, crucially, ensures that the economic value generated remains within the UK economy.

Professor Leonard also highlighted how the increasing importing of products, materials and systems is having direct consequences in industries, like construction, which is increasingly dominated by imported products and raw materials.

He argues that the construction industry and the UK building products sector should be at the heart of any long-term employment strategy, as together they have the potential to create hundreds of thousands of skilled jobs, support regional growth, attract investment and generate tax revenues.

However, these industries are currently facing significant challenges, including high energy costs, rising employment costs and Government policies that favour offshore manufacturing and the importation of raw materials in direct substitution for those available in the UK.

“If Britain genuinely wishes to tackle youth unemployment and the growing levels of economic inactivity among older workers, the answer is not simply to create more training places. The answer is to create the economic conditions that will result in more full-time skilled jobs,” he advised.

“That means supporting British manufacturing through procurement policy and advice, encouraging investment in domestic production, strengthening local supply chains, reducing barriers to growth and restoring confidence in housebuilding and infrastructure delivery.

“It means pursuing a genuine ‘Get Britain Building’ strategy that places UK jobs, skills and economic value at its centre.”

He added, “Young people do not want endless programmes. They want careers, including apprenticeships. Employers do not want subsidies. They want customers, demand and confidence to invest. Colleges and universities can only train people for opportunities that exist.

“Without growth, every new initiative becomes little more than a sticking plaster. With UK-driven economic growth, employment follows naturally.

“The solution to the Neet crisis and indeed the growing number of over 50s out of work is not simply more education or grants.

“It is about making and building things here and creating an economy that once again generates the skilled, productive and sustainable jobs that Britain needs.”