By Irfan Dadabhai, Founder, LexPact
Most recruitment agencies have Terms of Business. Most of them won’t hold up when a client hires a candidate directly and calls it something else.
That’s not a legal technicality. It’s a billing problem. Agencies lose fees every year — sometimes four or five figures per placement — because their ToB doesn’t do what they assume it does. The clauses are there, but they’re vague enough to give a determined client room to dispute.
There are five specific gaps that come up again and again. Here’s what they are and what to fix.
- The introduction definition
The most common dispute starts here: who actually counts as an “introduced candidate”? A client might argue that if they’d already spoken to the candidate at a networking event, or found their CV on LinkedIn before your email arrived, your introduction doesn’t count.
If your ToB doesn’t define “introduction” precisely — the date of first presentation, the medium (email, LinkedIn, call), and the fact that the connection was facilitated by your agency — you’ve given them an argument. The fix is one paragraph: “An introduction is deemed to occur when the agency brings the candidate to the client’s attention, regardless of any prior awareness of the candidate through other sources.”
The Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 (the Conduct Regs) requires agencies to confirm terms in writing before introductions take place. That confirmation matters, but it’s the definition within those terms that does the work.
- Fee crystallisation
Your fee shouldn’t crystallise at offer — it should crystallise at introduction. The practical difference is this: if you define the fee trigger as “when an offer of employment is made and accepted,” a client can take your candidate, wait six months, then hire them through a different recruiter and argue your fee never triggered.
The clause should say: “The fee becomes payable when the client, or any associated company, engages in any capacity — permanent, contract, or consultancy — any candidate introduced by the agency, within 12 to 24 months of the introduction date.” The time window and the “any capacity” language are both load-bearing.
- The backdoor hire clause
This is the clause most agencies have but most write badly. A backdoor hire happens when a client uses your introduction to identify a candidate, then approaches them directly — often months later — to avoid your fee.
A weak backdoor clause says something like “if the client hires outside the agency’s process.” That’s easy to dispute. A solid one specifies the time window (12 months minimum, 24 is better), covers all forms of engagement (employment, contract, partnership, directorship, consultancy through the candidate’s own company), and extends to group companies and subsidiary businesses. Without the group company extension, a FTSE 250 client can route the hire through a subsidiary and technically comply.
- The rebate schedule
Clients always ask about rebates. If your ToB doesn’t specify exactly when rebates expire, at what rate, and on what conditions, you’re negotiating from a weak position after the fact.
Standard practice: 100% rebate if the candidate leaves within four weeks, stepping down to 50% between four and eight weeks, zero after that. The conditions matter too — rebates don’t apply if the client changes the role, redundancy occurs, or the client terminates the candidate.
Write it as a table in the ToB itself, not as a side letter you’ll attach later. Side letters get lost.
- Payment terms with teeth
“30 days” on its own isn’t enough. If you don’t reference the Late Payment of Commercial Debts (Interest) Act 1998, you’re leaving statutory interest on the table. The Act allows you to charge 8% above the Bank of England base rate (currently 3.75%) on overdue invoices from day one — that’s 11.75% annually. You can also charge a fixed compensation fee: £40 for invoices under £1,000, £70 between £1,000 and £9,999, and £100 for anything above.
Reference the Act by name in your payment terms clause. Most clients won’t push back on it, but having it written in means you can enforce it without issuing a formal legal threat first.
None of these clauses require a solicitor to draft from scratch. They require someone who knows what’s missing to read your current ToB and fill the gaps. Most agencies use a template they inherited from their first director, amended a few times by whoever was least busy that week. That template almost certainly doesn’t have all five of these.
Irfan Dadabhai is the founder of LexPact, an AI contract platform for UK recruiters and freelancers.
Photo: Unsplash