When the United Kingdom launched its autonomous sanctions regime following Brexit, policymakers promised a nimble, targeted approach that would surpass Brussels’ coordination-heavy framework. Three years into Russia’s Ukraine invasion, however, evidence suggests the UK’s independent sanctions policy has produced neither superior effectiveness nor meaningful strategic advantage. Instead, Britain’s approach exemplifies how sanctions are not working as intended, creating collateral damage whilst failing to achieve stated foreign policy objectives.
The UK government designated over 2,000 individuals and entities under The Russia (Sanctions) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019, yet internal Foreign Office assessments reveal a troubling reality. According to testimony in the Supreme Court Shvidler case, 92% of travel restriction sanctions targeted Russian citizens who had never visited the UK and never intended to. Former diplomat Ian Proud, who authorised approximately half of Britain’s Russia sanctions, confirmed that internal advice concluded individual and entity sanctions have “practically no impact within six months of their imposition.”
This raises fundamental questions about whether UK sanctions on Russia represent genuine foreign policy or mere political theatre. When Lord Leggatt dissented in the Shvidler ruling, he characterised the government’s justifications as “flimsy reasons” and “armchair theories” rather than evidence-based policy. His scathing assessment warned that courts failing to protect fundamental freedoms render judicial review “of little worth” – a constitutional crisis hiding in plain sight.
The Blanket Approach Problem
The most significant flaw in the UK’s sanctions architecture lies in its indiscriminate scope. Unlike targeted measures requiring proof of specific wrongdoing, British sanctions employ guilt-by-association principles that ensnare individuals based on photographs from years past or tenuous business connections. Eugene Shvidler, a British-American dual national, found all his global assets frozen not for supporting Putin’s regime, but for historical association with Roman Abramovich and serving as a non-executive director of Evraz plc.
Shvidler had publicly condemned the “senseless violence” in Ukraine and used the term “war” – language that would result in imprisonment under Russian law. Yet the Foreign Secretary’s press release labelled him among “Putin’s friends” and “hired thugs complicit in the murder of innocent civilians.” These baseless accusations, later quietly amended, demonstrate how international sanctions can devolve into reputational destruction without due process.
The impact of sanctions on Russia extends far beyond intended targets. Shvidler’s children were permanently expelled from their schools mid-academic year. His former wife and adult children lost banking services. The worldwide freeze – applicable solely because of his British citizenship – left him effectively stateless, unable to access resources anywhere on earth without Treasury permission for basic necessities.
Enabling the Enablers
Whilst innocent individuals suffer, the UK’s sanctions regime demonstrates remarkable inability to target those actually facilitating sanctions evasion. Herbert Smith Freehills received a £465,000 penalty for six payments totalling £3.9 million to sanctioned Russian banks during a seven-day wind-down period – yet over 100 investigations into law firms have yielded just this single public enforcement action.
British ship finance veteran John Ormerod allegedly purchased 25 tankers worth over $700 million for Russia’s shadow fleet through Marshall Islands companies, with funding from Lukoil’s Dubai operation. His case illustrates how professional facilitators create elaborate corporate structures specifically to circumvent EU sanctions Russia while enforcement resources remain woefully inadequate.
The question becomes inescapable: if major international law firms cannot navigate the sanctions maze without breaching it, how can smaller businesses possibly comply? This complexity advantage benefits well-resourced actors whilst crushing those without sophisticated compliance infrastructure.
Strategic Incoherence
Perhaps most damaging is the strategic contradiction embedded in UK policy. The EU’s 18th sanctions package includes provisions blocking future Nord Stream pipeline usage – effectively removing any incentive for Russia to negotiate sanctions removal since European energy markets would remain permanently closed. Why would Moscow care about lifting measures that offer no pathway back to prior economic relationships?
This “future-proofing” approach, combined with refusal to articulate clear off-ramps, transforms sanctions from pressure tools into permanent punishment. Former US sanctions architect Daleep Singh emphasised off-ramps as the most crucial element of effective sanctions design – yet neither UK, EU, nor allied regimes provide meaningful de-escalation pathways.
A Policy Reckoning
The evidence suggests UK sanctions policy prioritises domestic political signalling over genuine foreign policy effectiveness. Why sanctions on Russia continue expanding despite measurable failure to achieve stated objectives reveals a system optimised for appearing tough rather than being strategic. As Lord Leggatt observed, making it a criminal offence for British citizens to access their own assets worldwide “without the government’s permission” represents “a serious invasion of liberty” requiring “cogent reasons to justify it.”
Those reasons remain conspicuously absent. Until Britain develops sanctions policy grounded in evidence rather than political expediency, the regime will continue generating injustice without meaningful contribution to Ukrainian security or regional stability.
—
Photo by Klaus Wright on Unsplash