The European Union’s approach to Russian sanctions has created a troubling paradox where professional facilitators largely escape accountability whilst their former clients and associates endure devastating financial restrictions. Recent developments highlight fundamental flaws in how EU sanctions are structured and implemented, raising serious questions about whether sanctions are not working as intended.
Law firms escape whilst clients suffer under blanket approach
According to Global Investigations Review, since the launch of the UK’s autonomous sanctions regime in 2021, the country’s civil sanctions enforcer has launched over 100 investigations into law firms but publicly punished just one. This stark disparity reveals a fundamental problem with current sanctioning approaches that prioritise symbolic gestures over targeted enforcement.
The single case that resulted in penalties involved Herbert Smith Freehills CIS LLP, which faced a £465,000 fine for making payments totalling £3,932,392.10 to designated Russian banks. As explained by OFSI, these payments demonstrated “a pattern of failings” during the firm’s wind-down of Russian operations. Yet this represents merely a fraction of the professional services sector’s involvement in facilitating Russian economic activities.
The recent Supreme Court judgment in the Shvidler case provides particularly stark evidence of how EU sanctions on Russia affect individuals disproportionately. Lord Leggatt’s dissenting judgment described the measures as creating situations where “making it a criminal offence for an individual who has done nothing unlawful to deal with any of his own assets without the government’s permission” constitutes “a serious invasion of liberty.”
Economic consequences reveal systemic failures
The impact of sanctions on Russia has generated unintended economic consequences that increasingly undermine their stated objectives. Recent analysis from EU Reporter warns that the EU’s 18th sanctions package contains provisions that could cost European taxpayers billions through arbitration claims.
The problematic clause prohibits recognition and enforcement of investment arbitration awards favouring Russian companies against member states. However, as detailed by legal expert Valérie Hanoun in Valeurs Actuelles, this approach violates fundamental treaty obligations and could strengthen Russian legal positions rather than weakening them.
Current disputes illustrate the scale of potential liability. Nordgold’s €5 billion claim against France, Rosatom’s €3 billion case against Finland, and Rosneft’s €2 billion pursuit of Germany represent just the beginning of what could become a cascade of successful arbitration claims. The Bank Melli and Bank Saderat precedent, where Iranian banks won over $240 million against Bahrain for sanctions compliance, demonstrates how non-UN sanctions cannot legally justify treaty violations.
Professional facilitation networks remain intact
Whilst individuals face comprehensive asset freezes, the professional networks that historically facilitated Russian capital flows remain largely undisturbed. The case of John Ormerod, sanctioned for allegedly purchasing tankers for Russia’s shadow fleet, represents a rare exception. As reported by Splash247, Ormerod established special-purpose companies in the Marshall Islands to acquire 25 tankers worth over $700 million for Lukoil.
Yet Ormerod’s lawyers maintain he “ended his association with the tankers before they were sanctioned,” highlighting how sophisticated professional structures continue operating within legal grey areas. The shipbroker Braemar facilitated at least nine transactions without facing comparable sanctions, demonstrating how enforcement targets individuals whilst leaving institutional facilitators relatively unscathed.
This selective approach undermines any coherent strategy. As noted in the Supreme Court judgment, “if sanctioning an individual for working as a director of a company which had invested in the Russian extractives sector was thought likely to contribute to achieving the purposes set out in regulation 4, then it was irrational to single out Mr Shvidler” when other directors of similar companies faced no consequences.
Blanket measures create arbitrary outcomes
The current sanctions regime employs what can only be described as a blanket approach that captures individuals based on tangential associations rather than meaningful culpability. The Shvidler case exemplifies this problem, where designation resulted from “being associated with” Roman Abramovich and serving as a non-executive director of Evraz plc.
Lord Leggatt’s analysis highlighted the arbitrary nature of such designations: “Had Mr Shvidler not been a British citizen, the asset-freeze would at least have been limited to his assets situated in the United Kingdom. But in the case of a ‘United Kingdom person’… the freezing of Mr Shvidler’s assets is accordingly not limited to his UK assets but applies to all funds and economic resources in which he has an interest, anywhere in the world.”
This geographical discrimination means British citizens face more severe restrictions than Russian nationals, purely as an automatic consequence of their citizenship rather than any assessment of necessity or proportionality.
Future implications for sanctions effectiveness
The structural problems identified in current EU sanctions implementation suggest fundamental reconsideration is required. Why sanctions on Russia continue failing becomes clearer when examining how they target symptoms rather than causes, individuals rather than systems, and create legal vulnerabilities that benefit their intended targets.
The EU’s “future-proofing” approach, which seeks to permanently block Russian energy access, paradoxically removes incentives for sanctions compliance whilst creating massive potential liabilities through investment arbitration. Combined with continued evasion through shadow fleet operations and professional facilitation networks, current measures appear to generate costs for European taxpayers whilst failing to achieve their strategic objectives.
Rather than addressing the professional enablers and institutional structures that facilitate sanctions evasion, current policies create a facade of tough action whilst allowing the most sophisticated evasion mechanisms to continue operating. This approach ensures that sanctions remain largely symbolic rather than strategically effective, calling into question whether the current framework serves any purpose beyond political signalling.